Relabel ask templates test
De Semantic MediaWiki - Sandbox
Trying to understand how the Property:Has preferred property label interacts with #ask queries with plainlist+template, as reported in issue: https://github.com/SemanticMediaWiki/SemanticMediaWiki/issues/3548
Regular query
(edit to view its source)
| Page | occupationoccupation of a person; see also field of work (Property:P101) ᵖ | occupationoccupation of a person; see also field of work (Property:P101) ᵖ | Occupation | Ocupación | overridenoccupation of a person; see also field of work (Property:P101) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andrew Gomenyuk | Student | Student | Student | ||
| Ben Brode | Small Indie Developer at Blizzard | Small Indie Developer at Blizzard | Small Indie Developer at Blizzard | ||
| ... further results | |||||
Plainlist + template + named args
template
From Relabel ask templates test/ask_template:
<hr>
* Page({{{Page}}})
* P106({{{P106}}}): FAILS
* P106@es({{{P106@es}}}): FAILS
* occupation@en/fr({{{occupation}}}): ok
* ocupación@es({{{ocupación}}}): FAILS
* overriden({{{overriden}}}): ok
Query results
(edit to view its source)
- Page(Andrew Gomenyuk)
- P106(Student): FAILS
- P106@es({{{P106@es}}}): FAILS
- occupation@en/fr({{{occupation}}}): ok
- ocupación@es({{{ocupación}}}): FAILS
- overriden(Student): ok
- Page(Ben Brode)
- P106(Small Indie Developer at Blizzard): FAILS
- P106@es({{{P106@es}}}): FAILS
- occupation@en/fr({{{occupation}}}): ok
- ocupación@es({{{ocupación}}}): FAILS
- overriden(Small Indie Developer at Blizzard): ok
Questions:
- But why does it work only with the en/fr parameter-name, and not with original property name P106?
- Shouldn't it work also with property's page name? (or else, one edit breaks all existing #ask queries).
